On a memo from Matt Mahan (Mayor), David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4), Domingo Candelas (Councilmember, District 8), Peter Ortiz (Councilmember, District 5) and Pamela Campos (Councilmember, District 2), the council directed the City Manager to pause land use approvals of data centers and large energy use projects until the council has approved uniform standards, and to draft an urgency ordinance for council consideration on December 8, 2026, so that the proposed data center ordinances and development standards take effect immediately on adoption instead of after the usual delay (agenda). The chair said the vote concerned only the pause and the urgency ordinance, not the standards themselves. About 40 members of the public spoke, just over half of them asking for a moratorium or more time.
David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4) moved approval of the item (the pause on approvals and direction to develop an urgency ordinance for December 8); seconded. The clerk first noted Pamela Campos (Councilmember, District 2) absent; she returned, and the chair called the vote unanimous. Result: passed, unanimous.
A motion adopting the Planning Department's report on the 45-day citywide ban on data centers (File No. 261021), in accordance with California Government Code Section 65858 (agenda). It reached the Board as a committee report from the Land Use and Transportation Committee's Nov. 16 meeting.
Approval of item 39, same house, same call. Result: passed, 11-0 (same house, same call).
An urgency ordinance extending the citywide ban on data centers for 10 months and 15 days. It required nine votes and was passed immediately on first reading (agenda). Sponsored by Shamann Walton (Supervisor, District 10) with Jackie Fielder (Supervisor, District 9), Chyanne Chen (Supervisor, District 11) and Connie Chan (Supervisor, District 1).
Passage of urgency ordinance item 40 on first reading, same house, same call. Result: passed, 11-0 (same house, same call).
A motion by Monica Rodriguez (Councilmember, Seventh District) and Bob Blumenfield (Councilmember, Third District; President Pro Tempore; Chair, Planning and Land Use Management Committee) (agenda) asking City Planning to report with zoning code amendments that define 'Data Center' and set use classifications and zoning permissions for them. The committee adopted it on consent with an amendment read from the dais that also asks LADWP to report on state and utility rules for water and power for data centers and other large users, and to recommend an overall project wattage cap and a system for tracking data-center demand against grid capacity.
Adopt the motion with the amendment read by the committee chair, as part of the consent vote on agenda items 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 10. Nithya Raman (Councilmember, Fourth District; Vice Chair, Planning and Land Use Management Committee) and Adrin Nazarian (Councilmember, Second District) were absent. Result: passed, 3-0.
The council had adopted a 45-day emergency moratorium (Interim Emergency Ordinance No. 13899 C.M.S.) on approving any land use entitlements or agreements for developing or operating data centers in Oakland. Staff said it was adopted October 6 and would expire November 20. State law (Government Code 65858(d)) requires a written report within 35 days on steps taken; the council held a public hearing on that report and on an emergency ordinance (file 27-0178) extending the moratorium for ten months and fifteen days, which under the City Charter could be adopted the same day but needed seven votes. Staff said the extension would carry the work through October 5, 2027, while it drafts zoning rules covering where data centers could go and limits on power, water and air quality.
Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to open the public hearing. Result: passed, 8-0.
Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to close the public hearing and adopt both pieces of legislation: the resolution issuing the 35-day report, and the emergency ordinance extending the data center moratorium for ten months and fifteen days. Result: passed, 8-0.
Staff confirmed a December 2 study session on the General Plan Annual Report 2026. They said the next regular meeting, November 18, will take up data center policy and ordinance changes to set uniform standards for large-load data centers, along with several privately initiated general plan amendments that the commission will forward to the council with recommendations.
An emergency ordinance, brought by the mayor's office after an executive order, that pauses citywide for 45 days the acceptance, processing and approval of permits for new, expanded or intensified data centers, plus a resolution finding it exempt from CEQA. Staff said the city's code doesn't define data centers and currently permits them under rules for telecom switching stations. They cited the facilities' demands on electricity, water and land and the risk of higher utility bills. The pause has exemptions, including small accessory server rooms, public safety and emergency communications facilities, telecom carrier and utility facilities, and minor repairs that don't add floor area, power or water demand. It doesn't apply to federal land, including the Navy's NAVWAR campus near Old Town, where news reports described a proposed 400-megawatt data center. The agenda says the ordinance needed 8 votes under state law and isn't subject to the mayor's veto. The item was moved from Monday so at least eight members would be present.
Sean Elo-Rivera (Councilmember, District 9) moved the staff recommendation (CEQA exemption resolution, plus introduction and adoption of the emergency ordinance) with added direction that isn't written into the ordinance: staff notify the council within seven days of any data center developer inquiry; a set of principles for the permanent policy; progress updates from the working group, the first within 45 days; and lobbying by the Office of Government Affairs against a large data center at NAVWAR. Kent Lee (Councilmember, District 6; President Pro Tem, City Council) seconded. Result: passed, 9-0.
The roll call for introductions resumed after the commendations. A supervisor introduced a ten-month, fifteen-day extension of the city's interim moratorium on data centers. A supervisor introduced a resolution putting Public Works' street tree and sidewalk commitments on the record. A supervisor introduced a resolution urging the city and state pension systems to review their risk from AI investments and urging Congress to reject corporate bailouts. A supervisor introduced a resolution affirming election integrity and opposing intimidation of election workers and voters. These were introductions only; nothing was voted on.
Item S401 is an emergency ordinance that would put a temporary moratorium on developing, establishing, intensifying or expanding data centers citywide, along with a resolution finding the action exempt from state environmental review (CEQA). The agenda says the ordinance needs 8 votes under California Government Code section 65858 and isn't subject to the Mayor's veto. On Monday the item was returned to staff without presentation or deliberation, to be heard Tuesday, October 27, at 10 a.m. as Item S510. Public comment was still taken.
Item S401 returned to staff, to be heard Tuesday, October 27, as Item S510. Result: continued.
The commission's annual retreat, a study session with no votes. The Planning Director gave an overview of the department's workload. He said two things dominate it: data centers, with a new city data center policy heading to the commission and then the City Council, and the flood of state housing and land-use laws, which he said now drive most of the city's long-range planning work.
City Manager's Office staff answered commissioners' questions about data centers before the proposed citywide data center standards come to the commission on November 18 and the City Council on December 8. Topics included where data centers are allowed, how they are permitted, the revenue the city expects, and emissions. Staff also described a proposed change that would send appeals of data center permits straight to the City Council, where today the Planning Commission has the final say. A commissioner objected that it takes away a hearing where residents can speak; staff said it answers residents who want the council to decide controversial data center cases.
On October 6, 2026, the council approved a 45-day interim emergency moratorium, Ordinance No. 13899 C.M.S. (agenda). It pauses approval of land use entitlements and agreements for developing or operating data centers in Oakland. The item is sponsored by Carroll Fife (Councilmember, District 3; Chair, Life Enrichment Committee) and the Planning and Building Department and has two parts. First is a resolution adopting the written report that Government Code section 65858(d) requires within 35 days of the moratorium's passage. The report describes the measures taken to address the conditions that led to the moratorium, and the resolution makes CEQA findings. Second is an interim emergency ordinance extending the moratorium by ten months and fifteen days. The committee scheduled both for the November 10, 2026 special City Council agenda as a public hearing. It used Rule 24 to bypass committee review because state law deadlines require the hearing on that date.
Janani Ramachandran (Councilmember, District 4; Chair, Finance and Management Committee) moved, seconded by Rowena Brown (Councilmember, At Large; Chair, Community and Economic Development Committee; Chair, Education Partnership Committee), to approve item three as is, which scheduled items 3.1 and 3.2 as requested. Result: passed, 4-0.
A hearing on an appeal of the city's use of a CEQA infill exemption for a special use permit allowing a data center use of up to 20 megawatts inside an existing R&D building of about 97,800 square feet (agenda) on 4.86 acres in North San Jose, District 4. The permit allows no exterior changes. The tenant is NVIDIA, which uses the building for chip testing. The appellant, Citizens for Responsible Industry, argued that the project leaves out generators, cooling and other equipment, citing a separate air district application for a diesel backup generator, and asked for a full environmental impact report. Staff said any added exterior equipment would need a new permit and new environmental review, and that the city's decades-old data center definition, due for update in December, is why this permit was needed at all. The council denied the appeal.
David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4) moved to deny the environmental appeal and uphold the infill exemption for 300 Holger Way, per staff recommendation (seconder not named); Peter Ortiz (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed, 9-0. Recused: Pam Foley (Councilmember, District 9; Vice Mayor).
California Public Policy Group, the city's Sacramento lobbyists, reviewed the 2026 legislative session. Topics included housing bills, data-center bills that affect water planning at Burbank Water and Power, wildfire liability, e-bike rules, extra time to answer public records requests, the state budget, $1.2 million in state money for the Burbank Reservoir and firefighter protective-gear storage, and what they expect in 2027.
Staff's regular report on actions by the Board of Supervisors, the Board of Appeals and the Historic Preservation Commission that affect planning, including landmark designations, an interim zoning moratorium on data centers, and changes to the city's local environmental review procedures.
Hilda Solis (Supervisor, First District; Chair)'s motion would have had Regional Planning draft a Title 22 zoning amendment, with an environmental (CEQA) analysis. The amendment would define data centers by acreage, square footage, energy use and water use, and would ban large-scale data centers, such as hyperscale and AI facilities, in all zones. The motion also asked for a review of noise rules covering low-frequency noise and for a moratorium to be ready if a threatening data center is proposed in an unincorporated area. At Hilda Solis (Supervisor, First District; Chair)'s request, the item was referred back to her office. No reason was given on the record.
Janice Hahn (Supervisor, Fourth District) moved, seconded by Kathryn Barger (Supervisor, Fifth District), to approve the continuances and referral read by the executive officer, including sending item 14 back to Hilda Solis (Supervisor, First District; Chair)'s office (no vote on the motion itself). Result: no action.
A committee report and urgency ordinance putting a citywide interim zoning moratorium on data centers for 45 days. The Land Use and Transportation Committee heard it October 5 and recommended it as amended. State law required nine votes, and as an urgency ordinance it takes effect immediately once passed on first reading. While it lasts, city approvals of data centers are paused as the Board and the Planning Department study the effects on energy, water, air quality, land use and communities and write permanent rules. Planning must report back within 25 days, with a hearing within 35 days.
Pass the urgency ordinance on first reading, same house, same call. Result: passed, without objection.
The city's federal legislative advocate gave an update on Congress before the election recess: a stopgap funding measure, data center electricity legislation, a permitting reform deal, and the expired federal transportation bill, which funds highway, transit and rail programs. Information only; no action was taken.
The city's federal advocate, the city's federal legislative advocate, reported that a stopgap measure funds the federal government at current levels through December 11; that the House passed a bill asking states to make data centers pay the full cost of the power and transmission they need; and that the administration has proposed changing how some immigrants are counted in the 2030 census, which could affect federal funding based on population. Comments on the census proposal are due October 13.
The city's state advocate, the city's state legislative advocate, reported on the governor's final bill actions: a veto of AB 1383, which would have let local police and firefighters bargain for pensions as high as 3% at 55; a signed package of data center bills, including limits on permitting a data center before it files a water supply plan; and new wildfire recovery laws, including permanent mortgage forbearance protections after disasters. A resident asked the city to ban data centers; members said a possible local ordinance is already working its way through planning.